Not Understanding The Nature Of The Web - Complaints About Linking

Featured: Featured Stories | Picture Gallery

Question - Do Extramarital Affairs Help The Economy | Christmas 2004 Indonesian Earthquake News

Chat11.com Web Bible11.com MyBibleCenter.com

	The Bush Survival Guide - 250 Ways to Make It Through The NExt Four Years Without Misunderestimating the Dangers Ahead, and Other Subliminable Stategeries
Links: [50 State Center] Hillary's Secret War A People's History Of The United States

Not understanding the nature of the web

Complaints About Linking, Fair Use, and the threat of DMCA complaints

Subjects > Computers > Internet > Web
Here is a typical complaint that is sometimes received by webmasters who have quoted a few sentences from another site: (a few details changed to undeservedly protect the clueless)

For the "scraping" in question, the offending webmaster had used parts of 5 or 6 sentences to go with the directory listing. The funny thing is that 3 of them appear to be things the clueless webmaster borrowed from other reviews, or quotations from the book. In other words, the clueless webmaster complained about a good normal on-topic link to their site from a site who borrowed about as much from them as they borrowed from others.

Their link was of course removed, not because of the threats, but because of not wanting to continue to reward cluelessness. Another more deserving article covering the same ideas was found, and link to it now replaces the link that used to go to the clueless webmaster, and the following link was placed in the directory: http://sitekreator.com/SudsySoapBox/elizabeth_taylor_and_jewelry.html

In an [article on Search Engine Watch entitled Deep Linking Lunacy], Chris Sherman says:

• Deep links are nothing more than a URL and some words describing that URL. In other words: facts. Facts are not copyrightable.
• Sites that prohibit deep linking suffer from malignant stupidity, driven by a fundamental misunderstanding of the web and user needs. The whole point of having a public web site is to encourage users to visit, and deep links make finding and visting sites easy. Home pages, typically offering cluttered design and feeble excuses for site search tools, make finding content much more difficult.

See the article [Axioms of Web Architecture] for the details that lead Tim Berners-Lee (credited as the inventor of the World-Wide-Web) to this conclusions about links:

• There are some fundamental principles about links on which the Web is based. These are principles allow the world of distributed hypertext to work. Lawyers, users and technology and content providers must all agree to respect these principles which have been outlined.
• It is difficult to emphasize how important these issues are for society. The first amendment to the Constitution of the United States, for example, addresses the right to speak. The right to make reference to something is inherent in that right. On the web, to make reference without making a link is possible but ineffective - like speaking but with a paper bag over your head.

Related google searches:

• tim lee deep linking

Related articles:

• [Form Or Substance] an article that received complaints from anti-deep linking lunatics

List of sites and webmasters known to make these kinds of complaints:

• More coming soon....

Check out [Facts About Trees]

Bobsgear - Get A Free Enterrpise Wiki Space!
Review: The Bobsgear Project was started to develop a variety of Confluence plugins. This installation of the Confluence Enterprise wiki includes flexible attachments, many Confluence plugins, personal blogs, interesting articles, and more. Bobsgear already has spaces related to politics, art and photography wiki, technical issues wiki, ediscovery wiki, health, Christian theology and Sabbath School wiki, the bible, book reviews, and quotations. Bobsgear allows free signup, and invites anyone to create a free hosted Confluence wiki space.

NEW USERS CLICK HERE! for a quick introduction to Wiki.

Elapsed:1