![[Home]](/wiki.gif)
Judge Calls Jury Use Of The Bible IllegalJudge Calls Jury Use Of The Bible Illegal
 | Jury Nullification - The Evolution of a Doctrine |
 | Jury Nullification |
 | The Political History of Jury Nullification |
 | Jury Nullification - Empowering the jury as the fourth branch of government |
 | A Trial By Jury |
 | In the Hands of the People - The Trial Jury's Origins, Triumphs, Troubles and Future in American Democracy |
 | American Jury On Trial - Psychological Perspectives |
See more:
Subjects > Religion
Subjects > Jury
Full story: [Don't Take Your Bible To Jury Duty]
Death sentence thrown out because of jurors' use of Bible The Bible saves lives. Just ask Robert Harlan.
In 1995 a Colorado jury convicted him of kidnapping, raping, and murdering 25-year-old Rhonda Maloney, and shooting a bystander who tried to help.
Friday, Judge John J. Vigil overturned Harlan's death sentence because jurors illegally used Bibles while deliberating and quoted a reference to "an eye for an eye."
The crimes Harlan committed, Vigil said, were "among the most grievous, heinous and reprehensible" he had seen in his 18 years as judge. "If any case merits the death penalty, there cannot be serious debate about this case being that case."
But while jurors can use their personal convictions in deliberations, they can't use texts that weren't introduced at trial.
"Jury resort to biblical code has no place in a constitutional death penalty proceeding," Vigil ruled. The quoted Levitical passages, he said, "more than simply encourage jurors to follow the instructions of the court. … The biblical passages involved not only encouraged the death penalty but required that it be imposed when another life is taken. The passages also directed jurors to take guidance from, and obey, the government. They left the jurors no discretion."
|
Interested in Sar-El?